Critical Data Education to Foster Citizenship Committed to Social Justice
Abstract
Critical Data Education brings together statistical learning and critical engagement with data to support the examination of social inequalities and possibilities for democratic participation. We report an investigation on what evidence of critical inquiry and orientation towards democratic action emerged as four students engaged with social data in a participatory Critical Data Education project in Brazil. Drawing on critical pedagogy, civic statistics, and intersectionality, a narrative analysis of three episodes selected from eighteen meetings are presented. The analysis examines students’ engagement with data concerning Brazilian Olympic medal winners and socioeconomic inequalities across neighbourhoods, as well as a student-initiated proposal to investigate social issues using public data. The findings illustrate how statistical practices of classifying, comparing, and interpreting data provided opportunities for students to identify patterns involving race, gender, and territory and to consider possible structural explanations for inequalities. A student’s proposal to develop a public-facing investigation further indicated an emerging civic orientation, in which statistical knowledge was imagined as a resource for raising political awareness. These dimensions, however, did not emerge as a linear progression: evidence was stronger for critical interpretation and intended civic engagement than for completed democratic action. The study highlights the potential of Critical Data Education to connect statistical reasoning with critical inquiry into social inequalities, while emphasising the pedagogical work involved in locating, constructing, contextualising, and adapting data in response to students’ questions. Results demonstrates that Critical Data Education can create opportunities for civic engagement, although further research is needed to examine how critical interpretations and civic intentions develop into sustained democratic action.